Develop an alternative to CoinMarketCap, but with more features, and Dash as the sole sponsor.

Would you vote Yes to fund a Dash branded alternative to CoinMarketCap for $5k x 6 months?

  • Yes.

  • No, because _____________________

  • Maybe, tell me about ____________________.


Results are only viewable after voting.

TanteStefana

Grizzled Member
Foundation Member
Mar 9, 2014
2,861
1,854
1,283
Good morning Tante,

ICJR has already added a substantial number of features. Usability is also high on the list of things to do, so drop down menu for trading pairs shouldn't be hard to add.
And this is a long term effort to make it a make it and keep it a top-shelf premium website for all things crypto. Keep the recomendations and requests coming. The blankety blank drop in the price of Dash is adding some consternation to determining a fair price to get the rest of the dev work and marketing done. But some how, some way, we're going to get this done.
I actually had no idea you could type trading pairs in that spot, which is perfectly usable for now, but a hint would be nice to add so others don't overlook it, like I did :) In fact it was a complete accident i found that out :D
 

ICJR

New Member
Jan 7, 2018
26
6
3
27
@TanteStefana The input field there is powered/provided by the TradingView API, I can't edit that specific section but I am implementing a dropdown that lets users select all trading pairs available so the chart is only loaded if a user wants to view the chart and the pair is exactly what you are looking for.
 

ICJR

New Member
Jan 7, 2018
26
6
3
27
Has a domain name been secured yet? :)
@feedbands No =/ I have my eye on about 5 domains, domain re-sellers have purchased nearly every coin/crypto type domains, all the good ones anyway. Once we proceed with the proposal I plan on purchasing one of the domains we have been looking at. The main 3-4 domains I am looking at are being sold for several thousand BUT they will be more than worth the price.
 

TanteStefana

Grizzled Member
Foundation Member
Mar 9, 2014
2,861
1,854
1,283
@TanteStefana The input field there is powered/provided by the TradingView API, I can't edit that specific section but I am implementing a dropdown that lets users select all trading pairs available so the chart is only loaded if a user wants to view the chart and the pair is exactly what you are looking for.
Well, that might become too many pairs to scan through? Maybe just have the trading pairs that are available, and show them against ... ugh, does this make sense? :

BTC ETH USD Euro
Dash Dash Dash Dash
ETC ETC ETC ETC
BCH BCH BCH BCH etc

So the top is a main choice, and those below are the coins where they are actively being traded against the top list?
 

feedbands

Active Member
Dec 2, 2017
309
172
113
35
@feedbands No =/ I have my eye on about 5 domains, domain re-sellers have purchased nearly every coin/crypto type domains, all the good ones anyway. Once we proceed with the proposal I plan on purchasing one of the domains we have been looking at. The main 3-4 domains I am looking at are being sold for several thousand BUT they will be more than worth the price.
PM Sent. I've been communicating with solarguy on a domain that I think would be a game changer for obvious reasons. It's your proposal 100% but I do hope you consider the domain. You can likely acquire it for $2,000 but is likely worth millions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: solarguy

TanteStefana

Grizzled Member
Foundation Member
Mar 9, 2014
2,861
1,854
1,283
@TanteStefana Are you trying to say it would be easier to select the coin/token to limit the pairs then select the pair?
Yah, I'm so brain dead, but yah, LOL, After doing that, in my haze for the night, I thought, "he knows how to do that stuff, just shut up" LOL Seriously, I'm losing it, my brain is so fried!!!
 
Jan 12, 2018
88
59
58
27
Caracas, Venezuela
dashyouth.org
Dash Address
Xcu6uQQ2DoAgV6Q2G5jhN8pCNhtKdNLFVA
Hey guys.

I have one question, how do you plan on deciding which markets will be accounted when calculating the different stats? What metrics will you be using?

Also, would love to see you develop an app (for both Android and iOS) thats more functional and aesthetically appealing than the other options on the market. I believe there is great potential on that segment.

Overall great idea, wish you luck!

Cheers,

Santos
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlfredoLec

AlfredoLec

New Member
Jan 15, 2018
9
14
3
26
Caracas, Venezuela.
Dash Address
XdKRsDGqW4Ygjz3v3BcAd4gbCAvhZS4Y2f
Hello ICJR!

Great proposal! Have you thought on giving a list of exchanges and its characteristics? Also volume, not only in the last 24 hours like some do, that would be very useful for many new traders, I think liquidity is very important when trading.

Good luck, I really look forward for your proposal to be accepted!

Cheers
 

ICJR

New Member
Jan 7, 2018
26
6
3
27
@Santos Bermúdez Ruiz I thought about this and came to the conclusion that we ( the site ) should stay out of the decision entirely. By this I mean our job will be to list the prices/volume, etc. of all exchanges and allow users to filter out the exchanges they use/recognize etc. Otherwise you ( the user ) will forever be dependent or at the mercy of our ( the sites ) decisions, the CMC issue is the most recent example of being at the mercy of the site/service.
 

ICJR

New Member
Jan 7, 2018
26
6
3
27
Hello ICJR!

Great proposal! Have you thought on giving a list of exchanges and its characteristics? Also volume, not only in the last 24 hours like some do, that would be very useful for many new traders, I think liquidity is very important when trading.

Good luck, I really look forward for your proposal to be accepted!

Cheers
All of that data is already being collected and will be displayed on the next iteration/upgrade of the service. Next major update should be within 1-2 weeks.
 

ICJR

New Member
Jan 7, 2018
26
6
3
27
Yah, I'm so brain dead, but yah, LOL, After doing that, in my haze for the night, I thought, "he knows how to do that stuff, just shut up" LOL Seriously, I'm losing it, my brain is so fried!!!
No problem :D
 
Jan 12, 2018
88
59
58
27
Caracas, Venezuela
dashyouth.org
Dash Address
Xcu6uQQ2DoAgV6Q2G5jhN8pCNhtKdNLFVA
@Santos Bermúdez Ruiz I thought about this and came to the conclusion that we ( the site ) should stay out of the decision entirely. By this I mean our job will be to list the prices/volume, etc. of all exchanges and allow users to filter out the exchanges they use/recognize etc. Otherwise you ( the user ) will forever be dependent or at the mercy of our ( the sites ) decisions, the CMC issue is the most recent example of being at the mercy of the site/service.
Very well thought. Although I would love if the site could offer rating based suggestions for the selection of exchanges so that people with less experience have some guide for the selection.

Besides that, love the customizability idea!!

You have my support,

Cheers,

Santos
 

solarguy

Active Member
Mar 15, 2017
867
413
133
60
Hey guys.

I have one question, how do you plan on deciding which markets will be accounted when calculating the different stats? What metrics will you be using?

Also, would love to see you develop an app (for both Android and iOS) thats more functional and aesthetically appealing than the other options on the market. I believe there is great potential on that segment.

Overall great idea, wish you luck!

Cheers,

Santos
You, the end user, will get to pick and choose which exchanges go in to produce your data. Of the competitors in this space, the best example I saw allowed you to click a button to include or exclude S. Korean exchanges. So really, nothing even close to what ICJR is plotting.
 

solarguy

Active Member
Mar 15, 2017
867
413
133
60
And we now have a Dash ad in the sidebar, mostly as a placeholder. The kind/type/extent of the ad will be tailored to what the Masternode community wants of course.
 

demo

Well-known Member
Apr 23, 2016
3,114
263
153
Dash Address
XnpT2YQaYpyh7F9twM6EtDMn1TCDCEEgNX
Coinmarketcap refers to fiat money as capital.
This is unfair.
I would like this alternative marketcap to give to the viewer the option to choose his own coin as a reference coin.
For example this is what we see in coinmarketcap:
1 Bitcoin $134.752.409.816 $7.995,93 $9.851.830.000 16.852.625 BTC 7,49%
2 Ethereum $78.185.208.928 $802,05 $4.191.660.000 97.481.471 ETH 7,17%
3 Ripple $29.221.803.584 $0,749100 $1.031.490.000 39.009.215.838 XRP * 2,70%
4 Bitcoin Cash $16.759.821.443 $988,45 $1.141.660.000 16.955.625 BCH 7,25%
5 Cardano $8.993.997.061 $0,346896 $575.767.000 25.927.070.538 ADA * 1,68%
6 Litecoin $7.848.386.948 $142,39 $931.843.000 55.120.883 LTC 2,76%
7 NEO $7.285.005.000 $112,08 $637.513.000 65.000.000 NEO * 10,61%
8 Stellar $6.573.294.312 $0,356621 $165.600.000 18.432.157.140 XLM * 2,89%
9 EOS $5.296.284.770 $8,08 $683.385.000 655.597.628 EOS * 3,41%
10 NEM $5.156.909.999 $0,572990 $46.291.900 8.999.999.999 XEM * -1,12%
11 IOTA $4.821.595.591 $1,73 $67.222.400 2.779.530.283 MIOTA * 8,41%
12
Dash $4.302.342.334 $546,58 $80.634.900 7.871.329 DASH 7,23%

Why do they sort coins based on FIAT money capitalization? Fiat money is yet another coin.

So let this new marketcap sort the coins upon the choice of the viewer. I would like to sort the coins based on dash capitalization as reference, for example.
 
Last edited:

Nick Chant

New Member
Feb 9, 2018
33
4
8
40
This is a great Idea. I am about to enter a pre-proposal. But not having posted on the forums before I've got to get three posts before i can add links so apologise if you feel this message is spam. I've read a lot on these forums and solar guy seems like an awesome community member!
 

solarguy

Active Member
Mar 15, 2017
867
413
133
60
Thanks to the community for all the useful feedback for making our proposal.

https://www.dashcentral.org/p/cmc-alternative

I see we are getting some trolling from MrHack. He inquired about buying a share of the project privately, and now thinks it's useless and won't go any where. It's good to see the early and enthusiastic no-vote come out. This is what the democratic process looks like. Plenty of time for the supportive crowd to intervene.
 

RealMrHack

New Member
Jan 18, 2018
22
4
3
40
Solarguy its not trolling when. Clearly I amongst others
as an MNO dont see the roi for the network..

Yes for a limited potential I had personal interest for data mining, until i figured i could do it alternatively.
 

solarguy

Active Member
Mar 15, 2017
867
413
133
60
Regarding ROI.

ICJR has proven history of marketing a site to get significant traffic.
He already has a functional website up, along with a real roadmap to add substantial features. So there is a guaranteed deliverable.

The monetization plan gives Dash views from the ideal demographic. If the site grows slowly, the ad cost is tiny to Dash, and even at that small volume, the price 1/2 of the market rate.

If the site grows quickly, the value of the Dash marketing zooms up quickly, and still is 1/2 of the market rate.

If the site gains even 10% of the traffic CMC gets, the 1/2 price deal saves substantial costs for marketing, tens of thousands of dollars per month. That's real money in my universe.

And if the site really gains traction, the 1% cap could save the Dash community 100's of 1,000's of dollars.
 

RealMrHack

New Member
Jan 18, 2018
22
4
3
40
its about ROI for the network not for icjr

And also it would enter the dash network into implied agreement to be a perma customer
 

solarguy

Active Member
Mar 15, 2017
867
413
133
60
its about ROI for the network not for icjr

And also it would enter the dash network into implied agreement to be a perma customer
The agreement is not implied at all. It is stated right out front, and available as a signed contract with core. 1/2 price on the objectively measured ad cost, for life, and aimed at the perfect demographic.

Dash is under no obligation to fund this, but if they do, that's the big payoff. They get a signed contract for a killer price for life, with a cap that makes it super attractive in the event the site does well. But even if the site has only modest success, it's still a killer price for marketing to the idea demographic.
 

RealMrHack

New Member
Jan 18, 2018
22
4
3
40
Well first dash network pays to fund the entire development, icjr has no skin in the game, if it fails he still has been paid to create the site.

Then we must pay again for ads?

He should at the very least give the network 2 years of free advertising.
 

ICJR

New Member
Jan 7, 2018
26
6
3
27
Well first dash network pays to fund the entire development, icjr has no skin in the game, if it fails he still has been paid to create the site.

Then we must pay again for ads?

He should at the very least give the network 2 years of free advertising.
I have been talking to other MN's and began exploring this idea to return the funds to the Dash treasury https://www.dash.org/forum/threads/exploring-dash-proposal-rev-share-loans.28845/ let me know what you think.
 

solarguy

Active Member
Mar 15, 2017
867
413
133
60
Well first dash network pays to fund the entire development, icjr has no skin in the game, if it fails he still has been paid to create the site.

Then we must pay again for ads?

He should at the very least give the network 2 years of free advertising.
Most of the proposal funding is for marketing. He did a substantial amount of development work before he ever approached the Dash network. Don't forget, there is already a functional product. The funds for marketing is indirectly (but primarily) for Dash.

Perhaps you missed the part about paying for ads, at half the market rate. Would you rather have 12 free golden eggs, or half of a 100 golden eggs?
 

solarguy

Active Member
Mar 15, 2017
867
413
133
60
There have been concerns, or questions regarding the “poor” or non-existent return on investment that this proposal offers to the Dash community. My first thought was to ask if those with questions had actually done the math to calculate the ROI or not. Let's do that for a minute because the numbers are pretty revealing.

For a moment, we’re just going to ignore the possibility that we actually surpass the volume of CoinMarketCap. While I think that is possible, given the ambitious roadmap and features, we would have to get lucky to do that in a year.

Based on the marketing we are looking at, and the other competitors in the space, I think we can realistically generate 10% of the traffic that CMC has within the next 4-6 months

The average Google CPM ( Cost Per Thousand visits ) is $1 - $10 for normal sites, for the following scenarios I will use a conservative $5 CPM for simplicity.

10% of CMC Traffic: 36.8M Visits
Full Market Price: Visits x $5 CPM = $184K/Month
Dash Price: Full Market Price * 50% = $92K/Month
Thanks to the 1% Dash Treasury Cap, Dash Price: $40k
Actual discount or savings for dash, 184,000 - 40,000 = $144,000

Boom, $144,000 (amount Dash is saving) / $75,000 (amount Dash invested) = 192% ROI

Outside of the crypto industry, an ROI in 5-7 years is considered pretty good. That’s a 15-20% per annum return. Of course, crypto doesn’t exactly play by the typical rules. But an ROI of 192% in one month (after hitting 10% of CMC volume) seems pretty spectacular.

But again, this relationship with Dash was designed to be a good deal for Dash under many possible scenarios. Let’s say we are wildly optimistic in our projections and we only capture 1% of the CMC traffic by 6 months.

1% of CMC Traffic: 3.7M Visits
Full Market Price: Visits x $5 CPM = $18.5K/Month
Dash Price: Full Market Price * 50% = $9.25K/Month

Ok, still not too shabby. Dash makes 12% return on their investment, per month. If we fail to continue growing, Dash would completely recover the initial investment within 8.3 months.

But let’s consider the “wildly successful” scenario. With good marketing, great features, and continued development in response to the feedback of the Dash community, and the larger crypto community, what do those numbers look like?

100% of CMC Traffic: 368.21M Visits
Full Market Price: Visits x $5 CPM = $1.84M/Month
Dash Price: Full Market Price * 50% = $920K/Month
Thanks to the 1% Dash Treasury Cap, Dash Price: $40k

Holy crap batman, if this blows up to CMC-like volumes, the value of the ad to Dash is discounted by $880,000 per month.

So in every scenario we have looked at, from generating a mere 1% of CMC traffic, all the way to 100% of CMC traffic, Dash gets a good return, all the way to fantastic return.

If anyone questions our math, kindly point out the flaw or incorrect assumptions.