Welcome to the Dash Forum!

Please sign up to discuss the most innovative cryptocurrency!

Which masternodes voted and what exactly voted on various proposals (v2)

Discussion in 'Off Topic' started by demo, Apr 1, 2018.

  1. xkcd

    xkcd Member
    Masternode Owner/Operator

    Joined:
    Feb 19, 2017
    Messages:
    43
    Likes Received:
    19
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Dash Address:
    XrcWshofvVCpeXoZjTiYxwysV9w2szzjRr
    Having a look at the distrbution numbers more closely and comparing to previous months, I get the below table. Data in the cells is the number of Operators, top row is number of masternodes.
    Code:
    Number of Mastenodes
             1     1-5     >=50   No Votes   Uniquely Voted
    --------------------------------------------------------
    June     304   499     4      2456       576
    July     248   398     6      2525       483
    August   196   332     5      2631       442
    
    This does seem to suggest a drop off in participation and reduction in the diversity of the DASH ecosystem, again likely due to the bear market and weak hands being shaken out.
     
  2. xkcd

    xkcd Member
    Masternode Owner/Operator

    Joined:
    Feb 19, 2017
    Messages:
    43
    Likes Received:
    19
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Dash Address:
    XrcWshofvVCpeXoZjTiYxwysV9w2szzjRr
    Using same script I uploaded from 2 posts back, I am presenting the voting data from the September budget and vote distribution by MNO. When viewing the attached file the_results_dashd_29-09-2018.html be sure to be patient as the javascript takes a long time to refresh, just give it time and the page will update.

    Distribution of MNOs revealed at 29-09-2018
    The first operator includes all people who did not vote. All the rest are grouped by the way they uniquely voted.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002818 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000135 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000081 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000076 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000067 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000052 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000048 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000047 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000045 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000039 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000037 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000034 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000031 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000030 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000029 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000027 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000025 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000024 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000023 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000021 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000020 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000019 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000018 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000016 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000015 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000014 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000013 masternode(s)
    5 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    8 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    7 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    13 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    9 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    17 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    20 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    31 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    55 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    183 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)

    Summary of the changes over the last few months.

    Code:
    Number of Masternodes
               1     1-5    >=50   Not Voted  Uniquely Voted
    --------------------------------------------------------
    June      304   499     4      2456       576
    July      248   398     6      2525       483
    August    196   332     5      2631       442
    September 183   306     6      2818       391
    
     

    Attached Files:

    • Like Like x 1
  3. colofi

    colofi Member

    Joined:
    Sep 29, 2018
    Messages:
    13
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    48

    I ran the script in my dashd, during the three days period that the payment occurs, but the results and the distribution were not identical to yours.
    I was wondering, what is the reason of this incompatibility?
     
    #33 colofi, Oct 3, 2018
    Last edited: Oct 3, 2018
  4. xkcd

    xkcd Member
    Masternode Owner/Operator

    Joined:
    Feb 19, 2017
    Messages:
    43
    Likes Received:
    19
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Dash Address:
    XrcWshofvVCpeXoZjTiYxwysV9w2szzjRr
    Using same script I uploaded from 3 posts back, I am presenting the voting data from the October budget and vote distribution by MNO. When viewing the attached file the_results_dashd_30-10-2018.html be sure to be patient as the javascript takes a long time to refresh, just give it time and the page will update.

    Distribution of MNOs revealed at 30-10-2018
    The first operator includes all people who did not vote. All the rest are grouped by the way they uniquely voted.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002994 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000097 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000088 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000082 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000067 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000052 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000048 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000047 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000045 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000040 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000038 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000034 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000030 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000029 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000025 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000024 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000023 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000021 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000019 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000018 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000016 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000015 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000014 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000013 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    9 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    8 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    12 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    10 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    15 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    23 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    32 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    57 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    157 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)

    Summary of the changes over the last few months.


    Code:
    Number of Masternodes
               1     1-5    >=50   Not Voted  Uniquely Voted
    --------------------------------------------------------
    June      304   499     4      2456       576
    July      248   398     6      2525       483
    August    196   332     5      2631       442
    September 183   306     6      2818       391
    October   157   284     5      2994       371
    
     

    Attached Files:

    • Like Like x 1
  5. colofi

    colofi Member

    Joined:
    Sep 29, 2018
    Messages:
    13
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    48
    2994 didnt vote!!!!! :confused::confused::confused::eek::eek::eek:
    What shall we do to them? o_O
    Tax them for not voiting? :rolleyes::p
    Seize their voting rights for the next budget cycle? :rolleyes: :cool:

    Lets post a special proposal in the next budget saying:
    "Those who will not vote into this proposal they are considered deads, and they will be taxed":D
     
    #35 colofi, Oct 30, 2018
    Last edited: Oct 30, 2018
  6. xkcd

    xkcd Member
    Masternode Owner/Operator

    Joined:
    Feb 19, 2017
    Messages:
    43
    Likes Received:
    19
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Dash Address:
    XrcWshofvVCpeXoZjTiYxwysV9w2szzjRr
    Not so fast! There are legitimate reasons why a masternode may not vote, the best one at the moment is the pooled services, eg Neptune DASH they said they do not vote with their Mastenodes. Also, if we force a masternode to vote they may chose to throw a 'donkey vote' and mindlessly vote for anything which could have the side effect of making the voting more random. One thing that may improve voter turn out is a nicer way to do it, and that is what @jeffh is working on with his Dash Nexus. Hopefully that site better engages MNOs to vote as they should.
     
    • Useful Useful x 1
  7. colofi

    colofi Member

    Joined:
    Sep 29, 2018
    Messages:
    13
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    48
    We should mark those who officialy declare that they do not vote at all (Neptune e.t.c) and then the 10% that is required for a proposal to pass, should be calculated when we exclude Neptune e.t.c from the total MN population.
     
  8. xkcd

    xkcd Member
    Masternode Owner/Operator

    Joined:
    Feb 19, 2017
    Messages:
    43
    Likes Received:
    19
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Dash Address:
    XrcWshofvVCpeXoZjTiYxwysV9w2szzjRr
    Perhaps masternodes could send a signal that they are pooled nodes to exempt themselves from voting, I dunno. Seems like people would rather not leak any more information. it's a though one. :p
     
    • Useful Useful x 1
  9. colofi

    colofi Member

    Joined:
    Sep 29, 2018
    Messages:
    13
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Yes of course, but the ideal is for the shared masternodes to be able to vote too.

    It is not very complicated to add voting capabilities in a shared Masternode. Just ask the MNshareholders to give a separate dash address, even empty. Then assign to that address the number of the shares. Then they could use this address to vote. The outcome of the vote is the vote of the shared MN.

    And guess what, there is already code that can implement the above. This is EXACTLY the functionality of the dashboost project of @Pasta. Almost the same code can be used. In the code of dashboost, just disable the "add proposal" capability of dashboost, load the proposals from dashcentral (automaticaly or even manually) and launch the service.

    There is also the alternative solution to get the shares information from the masternode pool operator, and automate this. It is not a big deal, especially in case the sharedmasternode pool servers have a JSON interface
     
  10. colofi

    colofi Member

    Joined:
    Sep 29, 2018
    Messages:
    13
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    48
    I post some data from the banned mnowatch github site.
    I am afraid some of them are not accurate, because initially the shellscript took into account not only the active proposals but also the zombies ones.
    This bug was fixed in the_results_dashd_01-04-2018.html and after.
    They are .gz files.
     

    Attached Files:

    #40 colofi, Oct 30, 2018
    Last edited: Oct 30, 2018
  11. colofi

    colofi Member

    Joined:
    Sep 29, 2018
    Messages:
    13
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    48
     

    Attached Files:

    #41 colofi, Oct 30, 2018
    Last edited: Oct 30, 2018
  12. colofi

    colofi Member

    Joined:
    Sep 29, 2018
    Messages:
    13
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    48
     

    Attached Files:

    #42 colofi, Oct 30, 2018
    Last edited: Oct 30, 2018
  13. colofi

    colofi Member

    Joined:
    Sep 29, 2018
    Messages:
    13
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    48
    And here is the result file created by using data provided by dashninja.pl
    This file contains what ALL masternodes (online and offline) voted, for ALL proposals, during 2017.

    Beware, the file is huge. Be patient when loading it into your firefox browser. As with the previous files, this is not a zip file, but a .gz
     

    Attached Files:

  14. colofi

    colofi Member

    Joined:
    Sep 29, 2018
    Messages:
    13
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    48
    the_results_dashd_31-12-2017.html (buggy version. contains also the zomby proposals, thats why the one masternode owners are so many)
    The first operator includes all people who abstain. All the rest are identified by the way they vote.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002211 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000119 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000070 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000060 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000052 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000050 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000035 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000033 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000032 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000027 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000024 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000022 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000021 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000020 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000019 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000018 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000015 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000014 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000013 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    7 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    9 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    10 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    16 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    21 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    26 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    47 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    124 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    645 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)

    the_results_dashd_29-01-2018.html (buggy version. contains also the zomby proposals, thats why the one masternode owners are so many)
    The first operator includes all people who abstain. All the rest are identified by the way they vote.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002242 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000070 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000062 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000060 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000052 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000050 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000035 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000033 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000031 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000027 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000024 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000021 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000020 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000019 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000018 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000015 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000014 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000013 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    9 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    11 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    14 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    24 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    26 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    48 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    134 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    734 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)

    the_results_dashd_24-02-2018.html (buggy version. contains also the zomby proposals, thats why the one masternode owners are so many)
    The first operator includes all people who abstain. All the rest are identified by the way they vote.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002221 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000062 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000053 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000041 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000040 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000035 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000027 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000023 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000018 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000014 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000013 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    5 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    8 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    12 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    12 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    22 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    63 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    1647 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)

    the_results_dashd_01-03-2018.html (buggy version. contains also the zomby proposals, thats why the one masternode owners are so many)
    The first operator includes all people who abstain. All the rest are identified by the way they vote.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002185 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000137 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000058 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000041 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000040 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000036 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000035 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000027 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000023 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000018 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    12 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    19 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    25 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    64 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    1615 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)
     
    #44 colofi, Oct 31, 2018
    Last edited: Oct 31, 2018
  15. colofi

    colofi Member

    Joined:
    Sep 29, 2018
    Messages:
    13
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    48
    the_results_dashd_01-04-2018.html
    The first operator includes all people who abstain. All the rest are identified by the way they vote.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002453 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000097 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000082 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000076 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000056 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000049 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000047 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000045 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000043 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000042 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000037 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000032 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000025 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000024 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000022 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000021 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000020 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000019 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000018 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000016 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000015 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000013 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    5 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    5 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    7 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    15 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    15 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    27 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    17 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    30 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    83 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    276 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)

    the_results_dashd_30-04-2018.html
    The first operator includes all people who abstain. All the rest are identified by the way they vote.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002378 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000097 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000091 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000081 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000075 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000056 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000049 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000047 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000045 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000043 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000042 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000041 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000037 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000036 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000032 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000027 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000025 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000023 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000022 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000021 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000020 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000019 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000016 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000015 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000014 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000013 masternode(s)
    5 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    5 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    5 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    13 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    11 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    22 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    21 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    43 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    85 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    291 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)

    the_results_dashd_03-05-2018.html
    The first operator includes all people who abstain. All the rest are identified by the way they vote.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002381 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000097 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000091 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000081 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000078 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000075 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000049 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000047 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000045 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000043 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000042 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000041 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000037 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000036 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000032 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000028 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000025 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000023 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000021 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000020 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000019 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000016 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000015 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000014 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000013 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    7 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    7 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    16 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    11 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    23 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    23 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    44 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    85 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    262 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)

    the_results_dashd_30-05-2018.html
    The first operator includes all people who abstain. All the rest are identified by the way they vote.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002475 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000097 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000091 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000081 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000075 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000057 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000049 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000046 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000045 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000043 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000041 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000037 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000036 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000032 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000030 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000025 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000024 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000023 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000020 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000019 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000018 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000016 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000015 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000014 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000013 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    7 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    5 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    9 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    8 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    24 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    27 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    36 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    74 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    345 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)

    the_results_dashd_02-06-2018.html
    The first operator includes all people who abstain. All the rest are identified by the way they vote.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002465 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000112 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000091 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000081 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000075 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000057 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000049 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000046 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000045 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000043 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000041 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000037 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000036 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000032 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000030 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000027 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000025 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000024 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000022 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000020 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000019 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000018 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000016 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000015 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000014 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000013 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    8 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    11 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    10 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    25 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    25 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    35 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    79 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    307 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)

    the_results_dashd_30-06-2018.html
    The first operator includes all people who abstain. All the rest are identified by the way they vote.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002456 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000111 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000073 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000072 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000062 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000049 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000047 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000046 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000045 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000044 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000042 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000041 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000039 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000037 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000032 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000031 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000030 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000028 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000025 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000021 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000020 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000019 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000016 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000015 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000014 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000013 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    5 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    8 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    11 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    8 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    24 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    23 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    43 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    105 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    304 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)
     
    #45 colofi, Oct 31, 2018
    Last edited: Oct 31, 2018
  16. colofi

    colofi Member

    Joined:
    Sep 29, 2018
    Messages:
    13
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    48
    the_results_dashd_29-07-2018.html
    The first operator includes all people who abstain. All the rest are identified by the way they vote.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002525 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000118 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000114 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000081 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000075 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000055 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000053 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000046 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000045 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000044 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000042 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000040 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000034 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000030 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000025 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000020 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000018 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000016 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000015 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000014 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    7 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    5 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    9 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    13 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    8 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    20 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    27 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    37 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    66 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    248 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)

    Distribution of MNOs revealed at 30-08-2018 (xkcd's file)
    The first operator includes all people who did not vote. All the rest are group by the way they uniquely voted.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002514 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000114 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000091 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000081 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000076 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000070 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000056 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000049 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000047 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000045 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000037 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000035 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000032 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000030 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000029 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000028 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000027 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000025 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000023 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000020 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000019 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000018 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000016 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000015 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000014 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000013 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    8 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    5 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    7 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    11 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    9 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    23 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    20 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    27 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    62 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    202 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)

    the_results_dashd_29-09-2018.html
    The first operator includes all people who abstain. All the rest are identified by the way they vote.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002901 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000119 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000081 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000067 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000060 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000052 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000048 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000047 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000045 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000038 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000037 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000034 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000028 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000027 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000025 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000024 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000023 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000022 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000019 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000018 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000016 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000015 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000014 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000013 masternode(s)
    7 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    9 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    5 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    11 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    9 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    17 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    18 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    35 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    59 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    172 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)

    Distribution of MNOs revealed at 29-09-2018 (xkcd's file)
    The first operator includes all people who did not vote. All the rest are grouped by the way they uniquely voted.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002818 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000135 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000081 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000076 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000067 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000052 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000048 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000047 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000045 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000039 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000037 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000034 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000031 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000030 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000029 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000027 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000025 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000024 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000023 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000021 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000020 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000019 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000018 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000016 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000015 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000014 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000013 masternode(s)
    5 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    3 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    8 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    7 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    13 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    9 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    17 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    20 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    31 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    55 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    183 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)

    Distribution of MNOs revealed at 30-10-2018 (xkcd's file)
    The first operator includes all people who did not vote. All the rest are grouped by the way they uniquely voted.
    1 operator(s) control(s) 002994 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000097 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000088 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000082 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000067 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000052 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000048 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000047 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000045 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000040 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000038 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000034 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000030 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000029 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000025 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000024 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000023 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000021 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000019 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000018 masternode(s)
    1 operator(s) control(s) 000017 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000016 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000015 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000014 masternode(s)
    2 operator(s) control(s) 000013 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000012 masternode(s)
    4 operator(s) control(s) 000011 masternode(s)
    9 operator(s) control(s) 000010 masternode(s)
    6 operator(s) control(s) 000009 masternode(s)
    8 operator(s) control(s) 000008 masternode(s)
    12 operator(s) control(s) 000007 masternode(s)
    10 operator(s) control(s) 000006 masternode(s)
    15 operator(s) control(s) 000005 masternode(s)
    23 operator(s) control(s) 000004 masternode(s)
    32 operator(s) control(s) 000003 masternode(s)
    57 operator(s) control(s) 000002 masternode(s)
    157 operator(s) control(s) 000001 masternode(s)
     
    #46 colofi, Oct 31, 2018
    Last edited: Oct 31, 2018
  17. xkcd

    xkcd Member
    Masternode Owner/Operator

    Joined:
    Feb 19, 2017
    Messages:
    43
    Likes Received:
    19
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Dash Address:
    XrcWshofvVCpeXoZjTiYxwysV9w2szzjRr
    Thanks Demo, I mean @colofi .;) With the extra data I was able to extend the table back two more months. I cannot use the data prior to April as the results for single owner MNOs are way outside the expected.


    Summary of the changes over the last few months.


    Code:
    Number of Masternodes
               1     1-5    >=50   Not Voted  Uniquely Voted
    --------------------------------------------------------
    April     291   462     5      2378       553
    May       345   506     5      2475       584
    June      304   499     4      2456       576
    July      248   398     6      2525       483
    August    196   332     5      2631       442
    September 183   306     6      2818       391
    October   157   284     5      2994       371
    
     
    #47 xkcd, Oct 31, 2018
    Last edited: Oct 31, 2018
  18. tungfa

    tungfa Administrator
    Dash Core Team Foundation Member Masternode Owner/Operator Moderator

    Joined:
    Apr 9, 2014
    Messages:
    8,666
    Likes Received:
    6,641
    Trophy Points:
    1,283
    happy decentralisation i would say if the biggest "whale " has 97 / 115 MN's (out of 4900 MN's ) as shown
     
  19. colofi

    colofi Member

    Joined:
    Sep 29, 2018
    Messages:
    13
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    48
    The one who has 97/115/137 MN's/votes is not the biggest "whale".
    He is just the biggest whale who votes.
    He is also the biggest whale who does not use voting obfuscation.
     
    #49 colofi, Nov 1, 2018
    Last edited: Nov 1, 2018
    • Agree Agree x 1
  20. xkcd

    xkcd Member
    Masternode Owner/Operator

    Joined:
    Feb 19, 2017
    Messages:
    43
    Likes Received:
    19
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Dash Address:
    XrcWshofvVCpeXoZjTiYxwysV9w2szzjRr
    Correct @tungfa I have seen evidence of other Super MNOs (>60) on blockchain, many of whom have been selling this year.
     
    • Like Like x 1
    • Informative Informative x 1
  21. colofi

    colofi Member

    Joined:
    Sep 29, 2018
    Messages:
    13
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    48
    If we knew the active proposals during Dec-17, Jan-18,Feb-18 and Mar-18 maybe we could extract the desired information from the buggy "the_results_dashd" files.
     
    • Informative Informative x 1
  22. xkcd

    xkcd Member
    Masternode Owner/Operator

    Joined:
    Feb 19, 2017
    Messages:
    43
    Likes Received:
    19
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Dash Address:
    XrcWshofvVCpeXoZjTiYxwysV9w2szzjRr
    Voting on the November budget has now closed and we are able to take the final tally of the votes and masternode involvement in this cycle and I must say the results are encouraging this month! I am seeing marginal improvements in every metric, we seem to have more voters involved than previous and more individuals voting. Hopefully this trend continues and implies new people taking a stake in DASH and further diversifying the network!


    Summary of the changes over the last few months.


    Code:
    Number of Masternodes
               1     1-5    >=50   Not Voted  Uniquely Voted
    --------------------------------------------------------
    April     291   462     5      2378       553
    May       345   506     5      2475       584
    June      304   499     4      2456       576
    July      248   398     6      2525       483
    August    196   332     5      2631       442
    September 183   306     6      2818       391
    October   157   284     5      2994       371
    November  166   269     6      3005       380
    
    * The script to generate this data was uploaded a few months ago.
     

    Attached Files:

    • Like Like x 3
  23. vasazuzuhi

    vasazuzuhi New Member

    Joined:
    Nov 30, 2018
    Messages:
    5
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    1
    I changed the_results file a little bit, so that all IPs having identical voteshash to appear into the same row.
     

    Attached Files:

  24. Alba Nitich

    Alba Nitich New Member

    Joined:
    Monday
    Messages:
    9
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    1
    Thank you for the links, it's very interesting.
     

Share This Page