Recent content by peter

  1. P

    Should Platform run on all nodes or should Platform run only on High Performance nodes ?

    Something, that I cannot understand. Let me cite Solarguy on dashcentral.org: And furthermore, 10k offers better performance and better security...
  2. P

    Should Platform run on all nodes or should Platform run only on High Performance nodes ?

    IMHO you're completely wrong. You can modify the software, promote it, ask other MNOs to run your version, and so on. And every single MNO is free to do that.
  3. P

    Should Platform run on all nodes or should Platform run only on High Performance nodes ?

    This is just your interpretation. And actually a quite negative interpretation. You cannot know it. You don't know the number of Dash users, of forum users, of MNOs, and you don't know neither the number of silent persons in each of these 3 groups. But you know the facts: there are about 4 or 5...
  4. P

    Should Platform run on all nodes or should Platform run only on High Performance nodes ?

    Indeed, a mistake. Our positive feedback is dominated by a very negative minority. It seems, that it needs to be spelled out in bold and all upper case: POSITIVE FEEDBACK. With all the very good explanations from Sam, the 10k-HPMN solution seems to be the best choice for the first release. The...
  5. P

    Should Platform run on all nodes or should Platform run only on High Performance nodes ?

    Who are "we all"? I guess, that you speak about 4-5 individuals here on the forum. But there are certainly some hundreds of MNOs, and even more Dash users. Yes, because only a vote will really show, if, and how much we all are divided. P.S.: I've only 1k, but I'll vote for the 10k-HPMN...
  6. P

    Should Platform run on all nodes or should Platform run only on High Performance nodes ?

    I'm still not sure, if this is right. Could you please comment on my question for Sam please?
  7. P

    Should Platform run on all nodes or should Platform run only on High Performance nodes ?

    Without an additional collateral for the HPMNs, almost all MNs (because hardware is cheap and gets cheaper every day) would switch to HPMNs with the already mentioned downsides.
  8. P

    Should Platform run on all nodes or should Platform run only on High Performance nodes ?

    This is just an example. You could also say 45% / 40% / 5% / 10%, or whatever...
  9. P

    Should Platform run on all nodes or should Platform run only on High Performance nodes ?

    Some further thoughts: 1.) Issue with stopping quorum: It seems, that the impact of a stopping quorum is not so dramatic, since the devs voted for the 4k-HPMN solution (highest chance to be able to stop a quorum). That means, that a high collateral is not a big requirement. 2k should be enough...
  10. P

    Should Platform run on all nodes or should Platform run only on High Performance nodes ?

    Sorry, I don't understand/find the answers. For how long: perhaps maximum 24h, because this is the maximal duration of the quorum? Impact: perhaps no impact at all, because there are 23 other quorums, that could to the job? Self-correct: perhaps yes, after one hour (new quorum appears), or yes...
  11. P

    Should Platform run on all nodes or should Platform run only on High Performance nodes ?

    I don't think so. Again: Platform MNs are supposed to provide Core services too.
  12. P

    Should Platform run on all nodes or should Platform run only on High Performance nodes ?

    Ok. But then, why would the reward increase, when some of the MNOs switch the "platform" toggle? I guess, that I don't understand your logic...
  13. P

    Should Platform run on all nodes or should Platform run only on High Performance nodes ?

    I don't think so, but I can be wrong. This is, what I've understood: The reward for Core services is distributed among all MNs (platform=0 and platform=1). The reward for Platform services is distributed among all MNs with platform=1.
  14. P

    Should Platform run on all nodes or should Platform run only on High Performance nodes ?

    That was an error, sorry. I've edited my post.